three characters holding a straw

The Overlooked Center: Why middle managers deserve more attention (and Investment)

Posted by on May 22, 2025

three characters holding a straw
three characters holding a straw

Middle managers hold it all together  – Photo by Nik on Unsplash

 

WHAT ABOUT THE MANAGERS IN THE MIDDLE?

When we talk about leadership in higher education or any sector, really, we often focus on the top or the frontlines. Presidents and provosts. Faculty and staff.

But what about the managers in the middle? The people with titles of Associate Dean or VP; Assistant Dean or VP; Executive Director, Senior Director, Director, Associate Director. (We do not have a shortage of titles on our campuses that represent this layer of vital leadership).

There’s a group carrying the weight of change, communication, and culture… often without the recognition or resources they deserve.

They’re your middle managers and they’re the glue that holds your institution together.

The Weight They Carry

Middle managers are the translators of vision. The bridge between strategy and implementation. They are often the people who:

  • Turn broad institutional goals into real-life deliverables 
  • Manage the morale and workload of teams through ongoing change 
  • Calm the chaos of competing priorities and cross-campus collaboration 

Support people up, down, and sideways in your organizational chart

In fact, research shows just how central this group is and how burned out they’re becoming.

📊 According to Gallup (2023), only 3 in 10 managers feel engaged at work.


📊 A McKinsey report (2023) noted that “middle managers are increasingly exhausted, and their disengagement has ripple effects on teams and performance.”


📊 In higher education, a CUPA-HR survey found that institutions often lack formal development programs for middle leaders despite reporting widespread institutional reliance on their leadership.

That’s not a gap. That’s a red flag.

We Ask Them to Lead, But Do We Equip Them?

Middle managers are often expected to:

  • Drive change
  • Support employee well-being
  • Lead through crisis or conflict
  • Make strategic decisions without full context or authority

And yet, they’re rarely given the tools, training, or time to develop themselves as leaders.

Let’s be honest, many of us know what it feels like to be in that middle seat. You’re spinning plates, mediating expectations, and trying to lead with integrity even when clarity is in short supply.

I often reflect on my current conversations and think back to my time as a middle manager and find myself saying: “I wish I had someone like me when I was in that role.”

That’s part of what drives my work now.

Investing in the Middle: Not Just Nice  – Necessary

If you want a culture that adapts to change, a team that stays resilient, or a strategy that actually sticks you need strong middle managers.

That’s why I created Leading In Between a leadership development experience designed to equip, elevate, and support those holding it all together.

Let’s Start Paying Attention to the Middle

Want to learn more or send this to someone who is that glue?

Because when we invest in middle managers, we’re not just supporting individuals, we’re reinforcing the very foundation of our institutions.

Curious about learning more:

📚 Citations and Data Sources

  1. Harvard Business Review (2025)
    🔗 What’s the Future of Middle Management?

  2. The Times (2024)
    🔗 Don’t Be So Hard on Your Boss – They’ve Just Been Promoted Too Far

  3. Gallup (2025)
    🔗 State of the Global Workplace

  4. Inside Higher Ed (2022)
    🔗 How Middle Managers in Academe Can Be Best Trained

  5. University of Reading – Research Paper
    🔗  Supporting Middle Leaders in Higher Education

  6. McKinsey & Company
    🔗 Stop Wasting Your Most Precious Resource – Middle Managers